Mill to close Sept. 2
BANGOR DAILY NEWS FILE PHOTO
Ted McNally, a millworker for nearly 45 years, leaves after a shift in May, a day after Katahdin Paper Co. announced it might have to close its Millinocket operation indefinitely July 28 because of record oil prices.
By Nick Sambides Jr.
BDN Staff

MILLINOCKET, Maine - The Katahdin Paper Co. mill will shut down indefinitely on or about Sept. 2, but will reopen next year with a biomass boiler that will end the mill’s total dependence on oil, Gov. John Baldacci said Tuesday.

Union leaders and management supervisors began telling the mill’s approximately 208 workers of the shutdown Tuesday morning, said Glenn Saucier, the mill’s personnel department director and spokesman.

“We don’t have the orders,” Saucier said. “We will keep it going to fulfill our present orders and we will shut it down.”

Baldacci said officials at Brookfield Asset Management of Toronto, the mill’s owner, have assured him that talks with alternative energy providers will produce a boiler to replace oil in the mill’s production of steam and allow the 2009 reopening.

“You have a company that is committed to reopening this mill,” Baldacci said Tuesday from Denver where he is attending the Democratic National Convention. “Whether people believe it or not, I do. They have a viable business plan, a mill that makes a fine product, and a highly skilled work force.”

“If it weren’t a good business plan here, I would say look, let’s fold our cards and let’s go home, but there is a good plan here,” Baldacci added.

The shutdown is expected to hurt the Katahdin region economy and will also affect the Katahdin Paper Co. LLC mill in East Millinocket, which makes directory paper. Some East Millinocket jobs will be lost due to a management restructuring and “bumping,” a union practice that allows senior workers to keep jobs at either mill.

Exactly how many layoffs will occur is unknown, Saucier said. Management and unions continue to negotiate the layoffs’ impact and management also plans to maintain the Millinocket mill until it restarts with a new power supply.

Mill managers, state officials and biomass firms have been talking about a biomass solution since May 29, when management announced it would indefinitely close the mill and temporarily lay off 208 workers due to the rising cost of oil. The mill burned more than 400,000 barrels in 2007.

The shutdown date has been pushed back repeatedly by strong customer response, vastly improved energy efficiency and government aid with the negotiation. The mill’s No. 11 paper machine — Maine’s newest such machine — is valued at $150 million and has had a loyal customer base that was fronting some money to help keep the mill running, managers have said.

That’s why the abruptness of Tuesday’s announcement seemed to catch everyone, including the governor, by surprise.

Baldacci said he didn’t learn of the shutdown date until Monday, despite his staff’s almost continuous contact with Brookfield officials, who told him “a week or two ago” that they would be reopening the mill but needed an earlier shutdown date than expected.

Baldacci had hoped that the mill would run until December or January and reopen in the spring. The governor wanted more time to announce a reopening plan and timeline and expressed his disappointment to Brookfield CEO Peter Gordon on Monday, he said.

The shutdown “was to be expected but at the same time, I think it could have been handled so much better,” Baldacci said. “I was given an indication they would have an end date sooner and a whole revitalization package to put forward.

“This is still a private business and they are making their decision,” Baldacci said, “but they recognize now that they need cooperation and partnership [with the state]. We have to have these commitments in public and underlined so people know what’s taking place here.”

The mill and its East Millinocket counterpart, which makes directory paper, employ about 625 workers together, Saucier said, making Katahdin Paper the Katahdin region’s largest employer. The Katahdin region economy never really recovered from the closure of the two mills, then owned by the former Great Northern Paper Co., in 2002. The mills reopened in 2003 with vastly reduced work forces.

Brookfield’s abrupt decision means that company workers and officials from the state’s Labor and Community and Economic Development departments have less time to prepare for their unemployment, Baldacci said.

The abruptness led to sour feelings in Millinocket. Some workers said Brookfield failed to inform mill manager Serge Sorokin, who was on vacation last week, of the looming closure until he returned.

Town Councilor Scott Gonya, a senior tech in quality assurance at the Katahdin Avenue mill, disputed that the mill’s lack of a replacement for oil, or a lack of sales orders, prompted the shutdown.

“They are simply closing us because they want to sell power and make more money,” Gonya said Tuesday. “They don’t care about our community. They only care about our stockholders making money.”

The mill’s owners have stopped taking orders from customers so that the company can sell electricity on the New England power grid, Gonya said. Brookfield owns the hydro-electric system that generates about 22 megawatts to help power the mill’s machinery.

Other workers claim that mill customers were quite prepared to guarantee orders well into the winter but Brookfield balked at operating the mill through the winter, when the cold makes the mill’s operation more expensive.

Gonya said that in earnings before interest and amortization, the mill made $973,000 in June; $1.2 million in July; and $800,000 so far in August.

“We can get orders. They just won’t take ‘em,” Gonya said. “There’s no justification for closing this mill at this time.”

Saucier could not confirm or deny Gonya’s statements.

“Maybe Scott knows something that I don’t know. I don’t know that,” he said of Gonya’s claims.

“That’s not what I have heard,” Baldacci said of Gonya’s statements.

Mill engineer Stu Kalgren said that Brookfield is an example of foreign predator companies that buy U.S. property and companies and shut them down.

“You have this state in particular being run by a bunch of environmentalist nuts and I don’t think they want industry in this state, but industry pays good wages and these industries and their workers pay significant taxes,” Kalgren said. “We need to protect these jobs.

“If you get a paper company such as ours that has gone from No. 10 in quality [according to some customer ratings] to No. 1 and from losing a million a month to making a million a month, I think that’s a significant step in the right direction, regardless of oil costs,” he said. “That shows me that someone is doing their job.”

U.S. Sens. Olympia J. Snowe and Susan Collins released a joint statement Tuesday calling the closure “deeply troubling and distressing.”

“We pledge to rally around these displaced employees and continue to work hand-in-glove with Katahdin Paper Co. and Gov. Baldacci to ensure that support and assistance is in place first and foremost to preserve these vital jobs, or help the workers transition to new employment,” the statement read.

Not registered? Click here
Email this
Print this
Comments
11 comments on this item

That mill is a fossil.

well Mr. Baldacci what are you going to do pay for my fathers oil bills when he loses his atteneats cause of the mill closing.

even thuogh it will re open next year when will that be jan, feb, march, april, may june, july, august,september,october,november,december or you may change it to never.

I will be so glad when your term ends and I hope the next person who becomes govorner has a better brain then you have.

While in Denver, Baldacci says the mill will reopen next year with a biomass boiler that will end the mill’s total dependence on oil, but if you believe that you should be tested for crack. Baldacci doesnt care if The People believe him or not, he assures us they come with a great business plan, but he failed to say whos money it would be. WAKE UP people this balding crook is going to stick it to taxpayers AGAIN, and the Canadian Crooks WILL get yet an even juicer TIFF. Not that it matters now, but how many companies get a fifty percent TIFF even if they close their doors. As many mill workers will be worried about a cold and uncertain winter, it would be only fitting and fair to let the CEO at Brookfield Bacon in on an impending eco injunction. That’s right, if you don’t clean up, Millinocket will make you pay up. Lastly, it was the environmental nuts that put people like Michaud and Baldacci in office, but yet some true idiots keep voting Democrat.

Since Scott Gonya is not only an employee and a government representative it is clear that his information is credible on this issue. The real issue that needs to be addressed is the way OUR state government and how it rescues major companies. If Great Northern was kept intact and for that matter when GP walked away in Old Town, then both emerging business's would not have the economic troubles today. The cost of energy would not be an issue today and both mills would be thriving. But since our State and the current economic advisors to the Gov, broke up the gems of both and the parts that employ people are in trouble. We can't reverse the damage that state leaders have put us in but you should demand better leadership from Augusta. I personally have presented 3 plans to Augusta that would have preserved the mills, and each time was told that they have other better ways to keep 200 people working in Millinocket and 450 working in Old Town. My last plan was presented in May and would have been in place by October and there are ways to bridge the gap from one energy source to a nother, but the state leadership has other plans to redevelop the mill.

The current net loss of taxes to Millinocket will be sustantial and life that we all knew is gone, unless we demand Augusta to change their course. Millinocket could still be the Gem of Maine, But the lights will go out with the current leadership in Augusta calling the shots.

The comments from Mr. Hartley are right on. Back in the golden era of Great Northern Paper Co, the employer WOULD not allow other businesses to come into Millinocket, they owned all of the land and completely and totally ran the town. With that beng said, the workers also could have cared less about other employment as they knew they would never make the money and benefits that they did at GNP. I have many relatives still there...most have retired, some have gained an education in other fields. It is a very sad time, once again, for the Town of Millinocket.

john mullen-1965 You can't blame Baldacci for the demise of the paper industry in Millinocket. Many,many factors have lead to this situation over many, many years. Looks like you might have to help with your fathers oil bills. Family helping family

I think the problem goes far beyond the state level. The mill is closing because it can't afford the cost of fuel for heating. I believe we can thank George DUH for that. Keep on voting for the republicans and everyone will be out of work.

Has anybody stopped long enough to really think about what has happened to the paper industry in Maine? First of all, it is much less expensive to ship the raw materials overseas, workers at the Maine mills get a very high rate of pay with benefits that allow them to work less and less. The insurance situation in Maine is not business friendly. Both employee health and workers compensation insurance. The cost of doing business in Maine is also unfriendly to any business and companies will go where the grass is greener. After all, they all have stockholders that are looking for a return on their investment. You can see what a temporary political fix will get you by the example set at the Red Shield plant in Old Town. Another Baldacci miracle that we will never live long enough to pay for.

The Millinocket Mill was let down by Michaud, ignored by Baldacci, and unknown to Allen.

It's impossible to lay the blame on any one individual, but it is possible to lay most of the blame on one group - Democrats, especially their union and environmentalist constituents. Neither constituent is totally devoid of some redeeming value, however, they have demonstrated what can happen when they take their beliefs to extremes. Can any of them rightfully demonstrate genuine surprise over the Katahdin Mill (and a number of others) shutdown? I don't think so. They can display anger, but not genuine surprise. And it hurts all of us economically, not just them.

Bush at fault for Millinocket mill closing, Well Ya Got Me On That One Einstein! Guess you must either be a head injured resident of Millinocket, or more likely you have no clue of the history of why this is happening. The town meeting concluded with one result, we are officially going to string up the Canadian Culture Club, and expose the parties that handed over the dams to them. This is not going to end without a very messy public battle.

You must be logged in to post a comment. Click here to log in.
 
Contact Us | Help/FAQ | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Copyright ©2008 Bangor Publishing Co.

Powered by: Creative Circle Advertising Solutions, Inc.